Re: Community input on possible change to Discord from Slack

Nashif, Anas


Zephyr project is not subscribed to any gsuite plans, free or paid. AFAIK we use google docs from LF in some areas. Maybe we should look into the non-profit “companies” option.

Never heard of, well hidden 😊




From: <devel@...> on behalf of "Jett Rink via" <>
Reply to: "jettrink@..." <jettrink@...>
Date: Tuesday, 21 July 2020 at 19:17
To: Henrik Brix Andersen <henrik@...>
Cc: Kumar Gala <kumar.gala@...>, zephyr-devel <zephyr-devel@...>, Ryan Johnson via Zephyr-users <zephyr-users@...>
Subject: Re: [Zephyr-devel] Community input on possible change to Discord from Slack


I know that Zephyr uses Google docs already, and that Gsuite is free for non-profit companies. Have we considered as an alternative? It may be free or part of what Zephyr is already paying for. It has conversations/threads and history, etc.




On Tue, Jul 21, 2020 at 3:23 AM Henrik Brix Andersen <henrik@...> wrote:

Hi all,

I have never used Discord before, but I given it a quick try the last couple of days.

My main concern is that Discord does not support threads (only quoting). This will cause all messages to go to the channel, making it more difficult to glance over the new topics.
It also makes it rather impossible to continue a discussion over several days or to follow up on a question or solution several days later, something that is often used on Slack today.

One of the bullets below lists shared accounts across servers as a pro for Discord. I am not so sure. The sign-on process was at least as difficult as with Slack.

Have we considered that once Discord settles on their business models, they too might start charging for unlimited message history?

Maybe it is just me, but there is also the question of familiarity with the service for our users.
It is my personal experience that many professionals within the embedded market know of Slack, but not many use Discord perhaps due to it being rooted in the gaming communities?

Henrik Brix Andersen

> On 17 Jul 2020, at 00.27, Kumar Gala <kumar.gala@...> wrote:
> All,
> We’ve had a few discussion in the Zephyr TSC regarding the need for maintaining history in our chat communication platform and the limitation that Slack imposes on this for free usage.  The general feeling is that having access to historical discussions is important for the continued growth of the Zephyr community.
> We have tried to engage Slack on a cost effective solution but unfortunately that does not appear to be an option.  A few different options that have been evaluated (Discord,, rocket chat, Microsoft Teams) and Discord seemed to be the best option and has had a fair amount of history with Adafruit (a Silver Member).
> Some requirements for Zephyr chat platform:
> * Maintain history
> * integration with other services (like GitHub)
> * private channels
> * ideally free - or low cost
> * no overhead for Zephyr Project (ie not having to run our own server).
> Pros of Discord:
> * Shared accounts across "servers" which are really just communities. Makes joining a new server very fast and easy.
> * Strong moderation tools (mute, ban, kick) per server. No need to wait for Discord to help.
> * Unlimited history for free.
> * Easy to join via invite link, chat and then establish an account.
> Cons of Discord:
> * Can get spammy when publicly listed.
> * Still in the startup phase so they are experimenting with business models. Currently "Nitro" subscription which unlocks server capabilities:
> * Closed source so interop with Matrix and IRC is tricky but doable.
> We’d like to get any feedback from the community at large before finalizing a decision in the TSC.  The topic will be on the July 29th TSC meeting and will review any email feedback that anyone has on the topic.
> Thanks
> A few links:
> * Current Open Source communities utilizing Discord:
> * Zephyr Discord:
> (NOTE: The Zephyr Discord is setup for testing purposes at this time)

Join to automatically receive all group messages.